A majority of investment bankers tasked with setting the first industry standards for calculating the carbon footprints of capital-markets activities have endorsed a compromise deal that would see banks report only one third of emissions related to stock and bond underwriting.
(Bloomberg) — A majority of investment bankers tasked with setting the first industry standards for calculating the carbon footprints of capital-markets activities have endorsed a compromise deal that would see banks report only one third of emissions related to stock and bond underwriting.
More than half of the eight-member working group chaired by Barclays Plc and Morgan Stanley voted for disclosing just 33% of so-called facilitated emissions, according to a person familiar with the process who asked not to be named discussing non-public information. Two members of the group, which was assembled in early 2021 by the Partnership for Carbon Accounting Financials, voted for 100%, the person said.
Unlike banks’ lending activity, where there is broad agreement on how to attribute emissions, assigning responsibility for facilitated emissions remains a contentious subject. Since corporate bond sales rarely remain on a bank’s balance sheet once they’re issued, some banks argue that assigning 100% of the CO2 to their books would be unfair.Â
Some dealers also want a lower attribution factor because their capital markets business are much bigger than their lending activities. Climate activists, which are increasingly targeting banks for their role in enabling planet-warming pollution, have lobbied for lenders to disclose 100% of facilitated emissions.
The option to disclose 33% of facilitated emissions was put forward earlier this year as a compromise to unlock a months-long stalemate at the working group. Other proposals included 100% and 17%, which reflects capital markets’ share of all industry financing and derives from analysis by the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision.
PCAF’s board still needs to approve the 33% attribution factor for capital markets before it becomes official guidance, the person said. Reuters earlier reported on the support for 33%.
A spokesperson for PCAF wasn’t immediately available to comment.
By including the impact of bond and equity underwriting, policymakers, regulators and investors will now get a much clearer picture of how green — or not — a lender is. Several major banks have said they’ll disclose their facilitated emissions and set targets to reduce them once the PCAF standard is published.
–With assistance from Frances Schwartzkopff.
More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com
©2023 Bloomberg L.P.